Welcome to Casey's, a beloved pizza restaurant located at 2105 E County Line Rd, Greenwood, IN 46143. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and friendly service, Casey's has established itself as a go-to destination for pizza lovers and snack enthusiasts alike.
The star of the show at Casey's is undeniably its famous pizza. Crafted from fresh ingredients and baked to perfection, each slice boasts a perfectly crispy crust that will leave you coming back for more. As highlighted by customers, the quality of the pizza couples beautifully with the friendly, efficient staff, creating an inviting environment where everyone feels welcome. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or fueling up during a busy day, you can always count on Casey's for delicious, satisfying food.
But pizza isn't the only gem you’ll find here. The menu also features an array of yummy snacks and refreshing drinks, including the popular Fairlife Chocolate Milk options, which offer a delightful twist on a classic favorite with lower sugar content and added protein. Pair it with some Angie's BOOMCHICKAPOP Sea Salt Popcorn for a tantalizing snack experience.
Customer reviews glow with praise, as one visitor noted the consistency of outstanding customer service from the staff, with special mentions of dedicated employees like Hayden and the “big guy with glasses” making pizzas. These personal touches not only enhance the experience but make Casey's feel like a community hub where smiles abound.
In addition to the food and atmosphere, the location is equipped with ample parking and a clean, well-maintained store, making it a convenient stop for travelers and locals alike. With a wide variety of offerings and a commitment to excellence, Casey's stands out as not just a pizza place, but a cornerstone of satisfaction in Greenwood.
For those looking to indulge in some of the finest pizza and snacks in town, Casey's is undoubtedly worth a visit. Get ready to satisfy your cravings with a blend of quality food and top-notch service that Casey's delivers seamlessly, time after time.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Lonnie Perry
04/10/2025
Casey's at the corner of Arlington Ave. and County Line Road is a fantastic spot for a quick and convenient stop. The store offers a wide variety of snacks, drinks, and their famous pizza, or their delicious donuts, which is always a hit with the kids and grandkids. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring a pleasant experience every time you visit. Whether you're fueling up your car or grabbing a bite to eat, Casey's provides excellent service and quality products.
McKenzi Johnson
07/09/2025
The employee Hayden needs a raise. He does a great job, super friendly. We come in here all the time and he’s always working. Definitely one of the best employees you have.
AJ Starkey
31/08/2025
Since they opened, they have continuously went above and beyond with there customer service and service in general. They're always polite and smiling! Hands down the best Casey's I've ever been to and I've been to 20+ different Caseys. I'd give more than 5 stars if I could.
Kyle Landon
22/08/2025
The big guy with glasses that makes pizzas is doing an amazing job and I watched him do one of the most kind and selfless acts I've seen. What a stand up guy and I will recommend Casey's to anyone if they are hiring guys like this. He needs a raise for sure. Great job hiring Casey's you are setting the bar high I tell you what
Charles S Johnson
28/07/2025
First time I went here. The store is clean and well stocked. Friendly staff. They have a kitchen and I think they have pizza. The only problem I had was that there was no toilet paper in the men's bathroom. Other than that it seems like a great store. Plenty of pumps to get gas. Also has handicap parking right in front. Check out my pictures. I was reading the reviews from other people. I noticed similar things about the management. I did not have any food but from what I read, I don't think I will take any chances. It's up to you.
Thomas Drury
24/06/2025
I stop at this location on occasion when I’m doing deliveries. The young lady working tonight as an cashier (07/19/2024 @ 8:00 PM) was extremely nice, courteous, respectful, pleasant and had a smile on her face with a great demeanor. There are multiple cooler doors with a large number of items that are not stocked - and this isn’t this first time I’ve noticed this. I did take pictures this time. There were two drinks that I was looking to obtain, both of which were unavailable. The employees here have always been great and easy to conduct business with.